Why Does Record Store Day Seem To Favour Vinyl Over CD?

As we navigate through the evolving soundscape of the music industry, the resurgence of vinyl records alongside the steadfast presence of CDs paints a vivid picture of a diverse and passionate music community.

Here at Now Spinning Magazine, we’ve observed firsthand the remarkable 14.5% year-on-year growth in vinyl sales as we step into 2024, a testament to the format’s unwavering allure. This resurgence is not just about numbers; it’s a revival of the tactile and immersive experience that physical music formats offer. Albums debuting at No.1 with a significant portion of their sales from physical formats in 2023 underscore the tangible connection fans crave with their favorite tunes.

The narrative of vinyl’s triumph is further enriched by the celebration of Record Store Day (RSD), an event that has evolved into a vinyl enthusiast’s major date for their diaries. While some argue that RSD has become predominantly a vinyl affair, overshadowing CDs, it’s essential to recognize the unique niches both formats occupy. As a collector with a foot in both the CD and LP realms, I appreciate the distinct appeal of each. Vinyl’s allure is magnified on RSD with colored vinyl, elaborate gatefold sleeves, and the allure of limited editions—features that CDs, with their compact nature, cannot replicate in quite the same way.

However, this doesn’t diminish the value of CDs, which thrive through the year with expansive multi-disc box sets, offering a depth and breadth that vinyl simply cannot accommodate due to practical limitations. These CD box sets have carved out a significant niche, providing music aficionados with comprehensive collections that vinyl editions would struggle to match.

It’s crucial to view RSD not as a competition between formats but as a celebration of music’s physical essence, primarily through vinyl. The event has indeed shifted from its original mission of bolstering record stores in challenging times to a broader celebration of vinyl culture. Yet, this evolution doesn’t negate the event’s success in reviving interest in physical music stores and, by extension, physical music formats as a whole.

The physical music landscape is richer for the coexistence of CDs and vinyl, each with its unique charm and appeal.  let’s remember that the heart of our passion lies not in the format but in the music itself. Record Store Day, with its focus on vinyl, plays a crucial role in this ecosystem, reminding us of the joy of collecting and the irreplaceable experience of dropping the needle on a record or pressing play on a CD player.

Phil Aston | Now Spinning Magazine

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x