Jack Bruce: I’ve Always Wanted to Do This – 5CD Box Set Review

Jack Bruce, Clem Clempson, Billy Cobham and David Sancious: four remarkable musicians, one fascinating studio album and two concerts that show what happened when the brakes came off.

This is one of my favourite periods of Jack Bruce’s career, and Esoteric Recordings have brought it back as an expanded and remastered five-CD box set. Alongside the original studio album, we get two complete concerts across four discs: The Bottom Line in New York City and the Rainbow Music Hall in Denver.

A remarkable line-up

Look at the names on this album and you might think you know exactly what you are going to hear:

  • Jack Bruce – bass and vocals
  • Clem Clempson – guitar
  • David Sancious – keyboards and guitar
  • Billy Cobham – drums

Jack Bruce, of course, needs little introduction to anyone who knows Cream or his remarkable solo catalogue. Clem Clempson had played with Colosseum and Humble Pie, while Billy Cobham’s work with the Mahavishnu Orchestra and his own Spectrum album helped establish him as one of the most exciting drummers in jazz-rock fusion. David Sancious brought another dimension to the band through his keyboard and guitar playing.

With a line-up like that, you could be forgiven for expecting full-on jazz-rock fusion from beginning to end. The studio album, however, takes a somewhat different path.

Hearing the album differently

We have to remember that this record was made in 1980. Music was changing quickly: the New Wave of British Heavy Metal was gathering momentum, while funk, soul and disco had all made their mark. Many musicians associated with jazz-rock and progressive music were exploring different sounds.

I’ve Always Wanted to Do This reflects some of that world. There are elements of jazz, funk, soul and rock, but much of the album has a relatively relaxed feel. There are ballads, beautifully controlled performances and moments where the band stretches out, particularly towards the end with “Out to Lunch” and “Bird Alone.”

I absolutely love it.

Would I have felt the same way in 1980? I am not so sure. At the time, I was immersed in bands such as Def Leppard and Van Halen, as well as listening to Sammy Hagar. I also loved the Mahavishnu Orchestra, Billy Cobham’s Spectrum and Return to Forever, so I might have approached this album expecting something closer to those records.

My musical horizons were perhaps narrower then, partly because there was only so much music I could afford to buy. Even when a favourite band changed direction, I could be suspicious. I remember feeling that way about The Doobie Brothers as Michael McDonald became such an important part of their sound. Now I love those albums too.

That is one of the joys of listening to music throughout your life. You change, your tastes develop, and a record you might once have passed over suddenly feels like just the thing you want to hear. This is an album I can see myself returning to often.

The playing and songwriting are impeccable, and Jack’s voice brings so much character to the material. It is a cooler, more restrained record than the names involved might lead you to expect, but there is plenty to enjoy when you listen on its own terms.

The Bottom Line: the brakes come off

If the studio album shows one side of Jack Bruce & Friends, the live recordings show another. For me, the concert recorded at The Bottom Line in New York City in March 1980 is the highlight of the box.

Here, these musicians have room to stretch out. The set draws on different parts of Jack’s career, including Cream material, and each member of the band gets a chance to shine. You can hear the chemistry between them and the excitement of a group of musicians responding to one another on stage.

A particular treat for me is “Quadrant 4,” originally heard on Billy Cobham’s Spectrum. When you have Billy Cobham in your band, you want to hear him let loose, and this gives him that opportunity. Listen to Jack’s bass playing too. It is a reminder of just how extraordinary he was.

The studio album does not always reveal the full force of what Cobham could do, but at The Bottom Line the band has the space to take flight. Those two discs alone make this a set I will want to revisit.

Live in Denver

The second concert, recorded at the Rainbow Music Hall in Denver in November 1980, is also well worth hearing. Across discs four and five, we get another chance to enjoy this line-up in a live setting.

The sound is good, although there are a couple of places where I would have liked Clem Clempson’s guitar to be a little louder in the mix. That is not a problem throughout: on “Clempson’s Blues,” for example, the guitar comes through beautifully. Jack’s bass and vocals sound particularly strong too.

Both concerts are enjoyable, but The Bottom Line has the edge for me, partly because of the performance of “Quadrant 4.”

Inside the box

The five discs come in a clamshell box, accompanied by a booklet featuring credits, lyrics from the studio album and an essay by Mark Powell. The essay looks at how the band came together and the circumstances surrounding Jack’s move away from RSO Records.

The set contains:

  • CD 1: I’ve Always Wanted to Do This – the remastered 1980 studio album
  • CDs 2–3: Live at The Bottom Line, New York City, March 1980
  • CDs 4–5: Live at the Rainbow Music Hall, Denver, November 1980

Esoteric and Cherry Red have done a wonderful job of looking after Jack Bruce’s catalogue, with releases including expanded editions of Songs for a Tailor and Harmony Row, as well as Halfway to the Stars and Smiles & Grins: The Broadcast Sessions.

The more I explore Jack’s music, the more I appreciate the breadth of his talent. He was an exceptional bass player and composer, but he was also such an expressive vocalist. These releases help keep that legacy alive and give listeners the opportunity to discover — or rediscover — the many different sides of his music.

I’ve Always Wanted to Do This is a fascinating album made by four outstanding musicians. The studio record has a warmth and a musical character that I appreciate more now than I might have done in 1980, while the two concerts offer plenty of space to hear the band stretch out.

ORDER THIS BOX SET HERE

Phil Aston | Now Spinning Magazine 

Phil Aston is the founder and editor of Now Spinning Magazine, an independent music website and YouTube channel dedicated to physical music formats, including vinyl records, CDs, deluxe editions, box sets and classic album reissues. A lifelong music fan, collector and former guitarist, Phil brings musician insight, industry experience and a collector’s passion to his reviews, interviews and features. Through Now Spinning Magazine, Phil covers classic rock, progressive rock, hard rock, heavy metal, blues rock, jazz fusion and related genres, with a particular focus on sound quality, packaging, archive releases and the emotional connection between music and physical media.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x