Why I Choose to Be Positive About Music

Every so often, comments can inspire a video.

Recently, a couple of comments appeared beneath my videos that did exactly that. They weren’t the sort of comments that call for a dramatic response, and I’m not going to put the people who made them on screen. But they did make me reflect on why I talk about music the way I do, and what I want Now Spinning Magazine to be.

One observation was that I always seem to be positive about the music I review. Do I really like everything?

The answer is simple: I choose to review music I feel something for.

The music has to move me

There are only so many days in the week. Listening to an album, researching it, making notes, recording a video and editing it all take time. I receive requests to review far more music than I could ever cover, and although I’m sometimes sent releases, I buy most of the music I talk about. I can’t afford everything, so I have to choose.

But the biggest reason is that I can’t go through the motions. I can’t sit in front of a camera and pretend to be enthusiastic about an album I don’t connect with.

Life is too short. I would rather walk down to the beach, give my wife a hug or go for a pint.

When I talk enthusiastically about a record, it’s because I mean it. Something in that music has reached me, and I want to share it with you.

I still want to feel some of the excitement I felt as a teenager in the 1970s, coming home on the bus with an album I had just bought from Virgin. That might sound like a tall order, especially when listening to something new, but it still happens. There are albums I hear today that make me think, Wow, this is brilliant. I can’t wait to tell people about it.

Sometimes the connection comes from where I first heard the music: being out in the car, perhaps, driving towards a sunset with an album playing. Later, whenever I hear it again, it can take me straight back to that moment.

That emotional connection is what I want to talk about. There are plenty of people who can tell you when an album was recorded, who produced it and which track runs for how many minutes. Those details matter, but what interests me most is how the music makes us feel.

Positive doesn’t mean uncritical

Of course, enjoying the music doesn’t mean I think every release is perfect.

If I buy a box set or a reissue and find that the records have come through the edge of the sleeves, the packaging is disappointing or corners appear to have been cut, I will say so. People who support physical music deserve to know what they’re spending their money on.

There have been releases I felt unable to endorse because of how they were put together. I know that a recommendation from Now Spinning can influence whether someone decides to buy something, and I take that responsibility seriously.

I’m comfortable being honest about those things. My criticism is directed at the decisions made about the release, rather than at a musician for creating something that happens not to speak to me.

There are people behind the music

I’m a musician, I live in a family of musicians, and I know many others. I know how much work goes into learning an instrument, writing a song and putting your music out into the world.

A song isn’t simply an object coming off a production line. Someone has made it. It might have come from heartbreak, grief, joy or an experience that means something deeply personal to them.

That doesn’t mean we have to like every song or album we hear. Of course we don’t. But there is a difference between saying, “That isn’t for me,” and dismissing someone’s work with cruelty.

You might listen to an album I’ve recommended and say, “I’ve really tried, Phil, but I just don’t like it.” That’s absolutely fine. We don’t all hear music in the same way, and that’s part of what makes talking about it interesting.

What I don’t have time for is abuse aimed at the artists or at the people discussing their music. I want Now Spinning to remain a place where we can disagree without being unpleasant to one another.

“Is this the oldest reviewer on YouTube?”

The other comment that stayed with me appeared after my review of Tony Iommi’s album. Someone asked whether I was the oldest reviewer on YouTube.

I replied, “Yes. Is that a problem?” They didn’t respond.

The question made me think about what my age brings to the way I talk about music.

In 1972, when I was 13, I bought Vol. 4 by Black Sabbath. I was there buying those records as they came out, and I saw Sabbath, Deep Purple and other bands in the 1970s. Later, I played in bands around the time of the New Wave of British Heavy Metal. I was part of that world.

So when I talk about Tony Iommi or Black Sabbath, I’m not simply reading a list of facts. I’m talking about music that has travelled alongside me for most of my life. My stories come from being there, and from what those records meant to me then and what they mean to me now.

I hope that personal perspective has value. Age brings its challenges, of course, but it also brings memories, experiences and stories worth sharing.

My Dad died when he was 56

There is another reason that comment about age made me pause, and it is a personal one.

My dad died when he was 56. I was 25 at the time, and I remember thinking that he was an old man. Of course, he wasn’t.

As I approached 56 myself, I found it difficult to imagine a life beyond that age. I had this fear that something would happen to me too. On my 56th birthday, instead of simply enjoying the celebration, I had a massive panic attack because I was frightened I wouldn’t make it.

I did make it, and I’m still here 11 years later. I feel very lucky to be able to do what I do.

My friend Paul Cook, the drummer in a band I played in called Tantrum, had experienced a similar fear. His dad had also died at 56, and we had both struggled with the thought of reaching that age. Sadly, Paul died of prostate cancer a few years ago. Losing him affected me deeply, and it still does.

Those experiences stay with you. They remind me that we don’t know how much time we have, and they influence how I want to spend mine and how I want to treat people along the way.

A place for like-minded people

The online world can feel very dark. There is a lot of anger, and sometimes it seems as though tearing someone down gets more attention than saying something kind.

I would rather try to be a little light in that darkness.

Perhaps it sounds naive, but I believe kindness is a superpower. If I can make someone smile, help them discover an album they come to love, or make a musician feel that the work they put their heart into has reached somebody, then that matters to me.

I often think of Now Spinning Magazine as a group of friends meeting down the pub on a Friday night. We bring along the music we’ve been enjoying, share a few stories and perhaps have a friendly disagreement about a record. Nobody has to like everything. We’re here because music means something to us.

That is why I do what I do, and why I do it this way.

Thank you to everyone who has been so kind and supportive, and to everyone who has helped make Now Spinning a positive place to talk about music.

Take care, and remember: music is the healer and the doctor.

Thank you for all your support

Phil Aston | Now Spinning Magazine

Phil Aston is the founder and editor of Now Spinning Magazine, an independent music website and YouTube channel dedicated to physical music formats, including vinyl records, CDs, deluxe editions, box sets and classic album reissues. A lifelong music fan, collector and former guitarist, Phil brings musician insight, industry experience and a collector’s passion to his reviews, interviews and features. Through Now Spinning Magazine, Phil covers classic rock, progressive rock, hard rock, heavy metal, blues rock, jazz fusion and related genres, with a particular focus on sound quality, packaging, archive releases and the emotional connection between music and physical media.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x